
THE SHORT ANSWER
The worst Avalon years are 2006 with 360 complaints, 2008 with 349, 2007 with 243 and 2005 with 228. Stuck or surging accelerators lead the early years, and headlights that drop out lead 2008. The 2012, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2020 and 2022 cars have the lightest files, though young cars file fewer complaints simply because they are young.
- Complaints on file
- 1,935 across 2005 to 2022
- Worst year
- 2006, with 360
- Share from 2005 to 2008
- 1,180, about 61 percent
- Lightest recent file
- 2022, with 8 and no recalls
The verdict: four early years carry most of the record
I pulled every NHTSA owner complaint and recall campaign for the Avalon from 2005 through 2022 and sorted them by model year. The pile is lopsided. Four consecutive years hold roughly six of every ten complaints, and every one of them has six or seven recall campaigns attached.
| Model year | Complaints | Mention a crash | Recalls on file |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2006 | 360 | 54 | 7 |
| 2008 | 349 | 23 | 6 |
| 2007 | 243 | 47 | 6 |
| 2005 | 228 | 36 | 7 |
If a seller is asking decent money for a car from one of these years, you need a reason to believe it escaped the pattern, and that reason has to come from the car's own paperwork.
What owners reported on the 2005 to 2007 cars
Vehicle speed control is the top complaint area for all three of these years, with 72 reports for 2005, 103 for 2006 and 85 for 2007. In plain terms, owners described accelerator pedals that stuck, returned slowly or let the engine race. Toyota issued a recall in January 2010 covering certain 2005 to 2010 Avalons, and its remedy was a reinforcement bar fitted to the pedal by a dealer at no charge.
There was also a floor mat campaign in 2009 for the same pedal problem. The older cars picked up other work too: a steering yoke campaign in 2005, an air bag inflator assembly campaign in 2006, a master cylinder campaign for 2005 and 2006 cars, and a seat heater campaign that reached into 2014 and 2016.
From an NHTSA owner complaint
An owner of a 2006 Avalon told NHTSA the accelerator stuck while the car crept into an underground garage at under 5 mph. Hard braking did not stop it, the car struck the garage door without any air bag firing, and the driver was hurt in the head and neck. The lesson: an old pedal recall is not finished until the repair is confirmed on that VIN.

2008 is a different kind of bad year
Of the 349 complaints on the 2008 Avalon, 209 fall under exterior lighting. Read them and a pattern shows: one low beam goes dark, usually on the driver side, and returns when the owner flips the switch off and on. It is more a nuisance than a stuck throttle, though it gets drivers pulled over and it is hard to catch on a short test drive.
From an NHTSA owner complaint
A 2008 Avalon owner reported that the driver-side low beam kept cutting out, even after new bulbs at about 80,000 miles. Police stopped the car on a highway. The shop found both lights working, and the fault came back some months later. The lesson: on a 2008, drive after dark and watch for dropouts before you buy.
Speed control is still the second area for 2008 at 45 complaints, so the older pedal problem has not vanished from that year either.
2009 to 2015: mixed, with a few bumps
Counts fall sharply after 2008: 91 for 2009, 46 for 2010, 106 for 2011 and just 30 for 2012. Then 2013 climbs back to 160, the highest of the later group. Structure, wiper and air bag topics show up there, and the recall list for 2013 includes an air conditioning drain hose, a wiper switch, an air bag control module and a pre-collision braking campaign.
- 2013: 160 complaints, 4 recalls, 21 injuries reported in complaints.
- 2014: 96 complaints, led by forward collision avoidance reports.
- 2011: 106 complaints, steering and electrical system topping the list.
- 2015: 54 complaints and 2 recalls, a quieter file.
The pre-collision recall matters because it covers 2013 to 2015 Avalons built from October 19, 2012 onward. Whether your particular Avalon sits within that window comes down to its VIN.
2016 to 2022: quiet files, with two caveats
The newest cars have the thinnest records: 23 complaints for 2016, 14 for 2017, 24 for 2018, 11 for 2020, 21 for 2021 and 8 for 2022. A thin file is partly just time. Owners of a young car have had fewer years to write in, so a low count flatters recent years.
The first caveat is 2019, which draws 71 complaints, mostly electrical and fuel-related, plus a fuel pump recall in November 2020 warning that a failed pump can stall the engine while driving. The second is that 2019 and 2020 cars are named in that pump campaign, so confirm the repair. Within this range, 2022 stands out with no recall campaigns on file at all.
Why the mileage history matters on an old Avalon
Avalons are bought as comfortable highway cars, so a lot of them have covered long distances. A fifteen-year-old model with a suspiciously low reading is exactly where a rolled-back odometer pays off for a seller. Dated odometer readings from title transfers, inspections and service visits let you check that the number climbs in a believable line.
- Look for a reading that drops or stalls between two dates.
- Compare the yearly pace with how the car was used.
- Make sure the most recent reading matches how worn the pedals, seat and steering wheel look.
- Confirm the open recalls for that exact VIN before you pay.
The federal NMVTIS database is there to shield buyers from fraud and unsafe vehicles, and a VIN-based report pulls title records from it.
What to run before you hand over money
- Take the VIN from the dash or the door jamb, then use the free preview on UsedVehicleChecks to see which records exist.
- Then judge whether paying once for the full report makes sense for the Avalon you actually plan to buy; prices sit on the pricing page.
- Look at the dated odometer entries first, then title brands and accident records.
- Check NHTSA's recall lookup with the same VIN for open campaigns.
- Have an independent shop inspect the pedal, brakes and, on a 2008, the headlights.
A clean report on a 2006 does not erase the model's record, and a flagged year does not condemn a car with a documented repair and honest mileage. The record only lets you price the risk.

Where this information comes from
- NHTSA complaints API: Toyota Avalon — source of the complaint counts and components by model year
- NHTSA recalls API: Toyota Avalon — campaign numbers, dates and remedies
- NHTSA owner complaint 11193550 — owner experience, paraphrased
- NHTSA owner complaint 11348822 — owner experience, paraphrased
- VehicleHistory.gov — purpose of the federal title information system
Sources and photos: Facts checked against the sources above in November 2026. Photos by Rafał Karoń, Alejandro Escamilla and Sander Jeurissen on Unsplash; diagrams by UsedVehicleChecks.
Keep reading
- Odometer Rollback Check by VIN: Run the Mileage Test Before You PayHow to spot a wound-back reading on a high-mileage car.
- How Many Miles Is Too Many on a Used Car? Age, Pace and ProofHelps judge an older Avalon's mileage against its age.
- Mileage Check by VIN: What the Recorded Odometer Readings ShowWhat the dated readings on a VIN can show you.
- Toyota Corolla Years to Avoid, and Why the Odometer Matters MoreThe same complaint-count method applied to another Toyota sedan.
Frequently asked questions
What is the worst year for the Toyota Avalon?
On NHTSA complaint counts it is 2006, with 360 reports and 7 recall campaigns on file. The 2008 year follows at 349, though more than half of those concern headlights. Both years are old enough that the car's own repair and mileage record counts for more than the model year.
Are Toyota Avalons reliable overall?
The counts here measure owner complaints and recalls, not reliability scores. They show the newer years drawing far fewer reports than the early ones. A later car with a documented history and a clean inspection is a lower-risk purchase than an early car with gaps in its record.
Does a recall mean I should skip that Avalon?
No. A recall means the maker has a free fix. The questions are whether the fix was done on that VIN and whether the car shows any sign of the fault. An unrepaired open recall is a reason to negotiate or walk, not a reason to dismiss the whole model year.
Which Avalon years have the fewest complaints?
Among the cars I counted, 2022 has 8 complaints and no recalls, 2020 has 11, and 2017 has 14. Recent cars always look cleaner because owners have had less time to report problems, so read these low numbers with that in mind.
Will a VIN check show whether an Avalon's odometer was rolled back?
It can show dated odometer readings from title and service events. If a reading drops or the pace looks implausible, that is a warning sign. A report cannot prove a number is right, so pair it with an inspection of the car's wear.
Now check the car itself
The guide explains what to look for. The report shows what this VIN has on record.