usedVehicleChecks

Kia Optima Years to Avoid, Judged by Engine Failures and Mileage

By NHTSA owner complaints, the Kia Optima years to avoid are 2013, 2015 and 2012, and 2013 alone has 1,387 filings against a typical year's 257. Most of the trouble is in the engine, and one car's dated odometer readings, repair orders and title brand tell you more than the model year in the advert.

Updated November 5, 2026 · Sources cited below

Have a VIN? Check that car

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.

View sample report
Open engine compartment of a sedan beside a panel listing three Optima checks

THE SHORT ANSWER

Of the Optima model years from 2008 to 2020, 2013, 2015, 2012 and 2016 carry the heaviest complaint records. The lightest belong to 2010, 2009 and 2008. The engine is named in 3,139 complaints, more than any other area. A flag on a year means checking the repair history, dated mileage and title brands of the car in front of you, rather than ruling it out.

Complaints on record
6,456 for 2008 to 2020
Median year
257 complaints
Peak year
2013, with 1,387
Bearing repair on 2011 to 2014 cars
15 years, unlimited miles

Six Optima years sit well above the median

NHTSA's public database holds 6,456 owner complaints on the Optima sedan for model years 2008 to 2020. The middle year logs 257, so each year is measured against that, not against other cars. Six stand far above it, and the engine is the area named most in every one.

Model yearComplaintsTimes the medianRecallsEngine named
20131,3875.49614
20151,0103.934623
20129213.585399
20167612.965427
20115942.315256
20145912.37284

The lightest records are 2010 with 75 filings, 2009 with 116 and 2008 with 144. Hybrids sit under a separate name and are left out. Each count is one owner's unverified account, not a ruling on any car.

2011 to 2014: a bearing recall and a mileage limit that moved

Recall 17V224 covers 2011 to 2014 Optimas with the 2.4 liter or 2.0 liter turbo direct-injection engine, about 443,825 cars. Kia's question-and-answer sheet blames metal debris left in the crankshaft oil passages for starving the rod bearings. A worn bearing knocks, can light the oil-pressure warning and may end in a stall. Dealers inspect the engine and fit a new long block where one is needed.

The mileage rule moved. An earlier extension on these engines stopped at 10 years or 120,000 miles, while the recall sheet says the repair for this condition is now free for 15 years with unlimited miles. Age becomes the deciding number, and the earliest cars in the range are near it. Quote the VIN to Kia and ask how it counts those 15 years.

Title paperwork photo with four key facts from Kia Optima complaint data

What mileage the failing cars showed

Among engine filings that state a mileage, the middle figures land a little under the old 120,000-mile line.

Model yearsEngine filings giving a mileageMiddle figureAt 120,000 or more
2011 to 2014403109,000162
2015 and 2016231100,00066

That is a sample, not a failure rate, since owners round off and many filings omit mileage. Even so, most sit below 120,000 miles, so a modest reading does not clear an Optima; it only calls for dated records.

2013: the heaviest year, with nine recalls

Engine is named in 614 of the 1,387 filings for 2013, and owners ticked the fire box on 114. The nine recalls include the engine bearing campaign, a fuel pipe check for cars that had an engine swap, two on a fuel hose that can crack from heat, and three on a brake control unit prone to an electrical short and an engine-bay fire. Campaigns are tied to build dates, so the VIN settles it.

From an NHTSA owner complaint

A buyer who filed in January 2016 had bought a 2013 Optima used, showing 24,952 miles, and had oil changes done away from the dealer. At 56,337 miles the engine began to clatter and the light came on. The dealer blamed sludge, said the oil looked overdue and refused warranty cover, though the owner said every change was done.

The dispute came down to oil-change history, so ask a seller for dated invoices, or ask the servicing shop for its files.

2015 and 2016: engine complaints, no engine recall

The engine is named in 623 of the 1,010 filings for 2015 and 427 of the 761 for 2016, yet neither year has an engine recall. Their recalls cover brake control unit fire risk, a fuel pipe check after engine swaps, air bags, an axle shaft and a trunk latch, so a clean lookup says little about the engine.

Kia chose software instead. A July 2018 dealer notice describes a knock sensor update for 2015 to 2018 Optimas with the 2.4 liter or 2.0 liter turbo engine, with a matching one for 2011 to 2014 cars. It senses early bearing wear and drops the car into limp mode. The notice promises lifetime engine cover for that single fault, for new and used owners, once the update is done. Ask Kia if the VIN shows it.

A 2015 where the scan tool and the dealer disagreed

From an NHTSA owner complaint

An owner who filed in June 2025 bought a 2015 Optima EX that the dealer had sold as having 101,000 miles. Inside two months the check engine light was flashing, a replaced valve timing part had metal on it, and the car kept dropping into limp mode and knocking. A scan at an auto parts store, the owner said, showed 150,000 miles, and a mechanic called for a new engine.

That 150,000 is an owner's report of a scan reading, not a verified figure, but it is the kind of gap a dated mileage history exists to expose. Compare every past entry with the dash before settling on a price.

A swapped engine leaves the odometer where it was

Recall 18V907 covers 2011 to 2017 Optimas that had an engine replaced under the bearing recall, under warranty or in the knock sensor campaign. The replacement can leave the high-pressure fuel pipe damaged or loosely fitted, so fuel can leak. Kia's filing counts 50,051 Optimas from 2011 to 2014 in that group, so a swap is not rare, and the dash counts miles on the body, not the engine. Ask for:

  • The repair order for any engine replacement, with its date and the odometer reading that day.
  • Proof that the fuel pipe check was done on a car that had a swap.
  • Whether the knock sensor update was installed, and when.

Branded titles and recall repairs

Kia's question-and-answer sheet for the bearing recall lists no eligibility restrictions. Some owners tell NHTSA otherwise: several filings say a dealer refused recall work on a salvage or rebuilt title. Those are owner accounts, not a published Kia rule, yet they justify a title check before buying a car whose main risk is the engine.

From an NHTSA owner complaint

The owner of a 2011 Optima filed in October 2026 after the car cut out as a family member drove out of a parking lot, with a burning smell and a clicking starter. Kia and the dealer both declined the recall repair, citing a salvage title. The failure came at 77,500 miles.

The lesson for a buyer: see the title brand first, since it may decide whether a dealer will touch recall work. NMVTIS, the Justice Department's title database, keeps each car's brand history from every state, alongside odometer, total loss and salvage records.

Before you pay for one particular Optima

  1. Match the VIN stamped on the car to the advert, then confirm the model year it decodes to.
  2. Search NHTSA's recall lookup, which costs nothing, and see whether 17V224 and 18V907 are open or done.
  3. Open the preview here; if the car stays in contention, buy the report and read the odometer entries oldest first, beside any title brands.
  4. Ask for engine repair orders and dated oil-change invoices, and ask Kia what the VIN is covered for.
  5. Have a mechanic listen for a knock, read the codes and drive it on hills, a highway and in traffic.

Nothing renews here. The preview is open to anyone, a report is bought once, and amounts are on the pricing page.

Highway road photo beside four numbered steps for checking one Kia Optima

Where this information comes from

Sources and photos: Facts checked against the sources above in November 2026. Photos by Willian Cittadin, John Kakuk and Masjid MABA on Unsplash; diagrams by UsedVehicleChecks.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

Which Kia Optima years should I avoid?

Start with 2013, 2015 and 2012, which drew 1,387, 1,010 and 921 filings against a median year of 257. The 2016 year follows at 761. Good cars exist in each, so a flag calls for a recall lookup, repair records and an inspection, not a flat no.

Is the 2013 Kia Optima a bad car?

It has the heaviest record: 1,387 filings, 614 naming the engine and nine recalls. Confirm the bearing recall was handled, find out if the engine has been swapped, and check the fuel hose and brake unit campaigns. The VIN shows which apply.

Which Optima years are the most reliable?

Complaint counts measure filings, not reliability, but 2010, 2009 and 2008 are the lightest at 75, 116 and 144. Newer cars look tidy partly because fewer owners have had time to file, so those years still need a title and odometer check.

Does high mileage end Kia's Optima engine cover?

For bearing wear on 2011 to 2014 cars, Kia's recall sheet gives 15 years with unlimited miles, replacing the earlier 10 years or 120,000 miles. For 2015 to 2018 cars, the knock sensor notice describes lifetime cover for one fault once the update is done. Terms change, so ask Kia about the VIN.

Do more complaints mean a worse Optima?

Only in part. Sales volume and age inflate raw counts, so each year here is set against the Optima's own median of 257, not against a different model. A recall is another matter, because Kia accepted the fault. For a specific car, its repair history and title carry the answer.

Now check the car itself

The guide explains what to look for. The report shows what this VIN has on record.

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.