usedVehicleChecks

Nissan Maxima Years to Avoid: What the NHTSA Counts Show

The Nissan Maxima years to avoid are 2004, 2005 and 2006, in that order, based on the owner complaints NHTSA has on file: 1,426 for 2004 alone. Those filings mostly describe transmission trouble, and a transmission that has done hard miles shows up in the mileage history, which is where a used-vehicle check earns its keep.

Updated November 5, 2026 · Sources cited below

Have a VIN? Check that car

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.

View sample report
Gear shift lever inside a sedan beside a panel of three Maxima points

THE SHORT ANSWER

Across model years 2000 to 2023, the Maxima years that draw the most scrutiny are 2004, 2005, 2006, 2000 and 2009, running from 3.18 to 13.39 times the median year of 106.5 complaints. Power train tops the list of components owners name. Treat the list as a reason to test drive harder and verify mileage, not as a ban on any year.

Complaints on record
5,461 across 2000 to 2023
Median year
106.5 complaints
Peak year
2004, with 1,426
Most reported area
Power train, 2,344 complaints

The five Maxima years with the heaviest complaint load

I pulled every Maxima model year from 2000 through 2024 from NHTSA's complaint and recall services. The years with any filings add up to 5,461 complaints, but the spread is lopsided: the middle year has only 106.5. Each year below is measured against that median, not against other sedans.

Model yearComplaintsTimes the medianRecall recordsTop complaint area
20041,42613.392Power train
20059488.92Power train
20065765.412Power train
20003773.543Electrical system
20093393.181Steering

Recall records here include a few aftermarket lamp campaigns from parts makers, so read that column as a rough signal, not a Nissan defect tally.

2004 to 2006: the transmission years

Of the 1,426 complaints for 2004, 934 name the power train. For 2005 the figure is 777, and for 2006 it is 393. Put 2004 and 2005 together and you have 2,374 filings, 43.5 percent of everything on record for the model. No other stretch of Maxima production comes close.

Owners describe the same pattern: hesitation between gears, jerking under throttle, then a failure that arrives well before the car feels old. Complaints are unverified, and a count cannot tell you how many cars were repaired and moved on without filing. Even so, a pile this uneven is the strongest signal in the data.

From an NHTSA owner complaint

An owner of a 2004 Maxima reported that the transmission hesitated when moving from first to second and second to third, with only 85,000 miles on the car. Take from it that gear trouble was not limited to worn-out examples, so mileage alone will not clear one of these cars.

From an NHTSA owner complaint

Another 2004 owner, who had bought the car used that year, wrote that it jerked, refused to accelerate for a while, and then the revs jumped. They argued they should not pay for a new transmission. A buyer should request transmission service paperwork before agreeing on a price.

Sedan dashboard and steering wheel with four Maxima facts over the photo

The 2002 odometer recall most guides skip

One 2002 campaign matters for anyone who cares about mileage. Recall 02V010000 covered cars with traction control whose odometer counted in kilometers instead of miles, without the label federal rules require. Dealers were to inspect the unit and swap the speedometer and odometer assembly when it was wrong.

A genuine replacement like that can leave a gap or a drop in a car's recorded miles. That is exactly the kind of honest rollback-looking entry that a dated reading history helps you explain, as opposed to a tampered cluster. If a 2002 shows a puzzling number, ask whether that repair was done and look for the readings on either side of it.

Older years with different problems

Not every weak year is a transmission story. For 2000, the electrical system is behind 181 of the 377 filings. In 2009, 168 of 339 point at steering. Crash-flagged filings peak in 2004 at 33, with 2002 next at 28 and 2000 at 27, while fire-flagged filings are highest in 2004 at 16 and 2005 at 10.

  • 2000: electrical faults dominate, so test every switch, window and warning light.
  • 2001 to 2003: air bag inflator recalls 15V287000 and 20V008000 list these years; confirm the free replacement was done.
  • 2002: a front suspension link recall and a crank sensor recall also sit on the record.
  • 2009: steering complaints stand out, so check for play and noise at low speed.

2016: few complaints, many recalls

The 2016 Maxima looks calm by complaint count, with 142 filings, only a little above the median. Its recall list is the longest of any year, at 8 records, and most concern the ABS actuator, with inspections and replacements spread over several campaigns. There is also a brake caliper mounting bolt check and a fuel tank retainer ring campaign.

Those remedies are free at a dealer, so an open recall is a to-do item rather than a reason to walk away. The practical risk is a car whose earlier owner never answered the notice. Search the VIN on NHTSA's recall tool before you commit.

The quieter model years

From 2018 to 2023 the whole run holds 85 complaints, and 2013 has just 62. 2015 has a single filing. Low numbers can reflect a good year, but they also reflect how few owners have had time to complain, or how few cars were sold. Neither tells you how the individual car you are looking at was driven.

Why mileage history outweighs the badge year

Think of a model year as a label on a production batch. Two 2005 Maximas can sit tens of thousands of miles apart in real wear, and a transmission that was serviced on schedule is not the transmission in the complaints. The dated odometer readings tied to one VIN show how quickly it was driven, whether the readings climb in order, and where an entry goes backward.

This site's preview is free and tells you whether readings turn up for a VIN. The full report is one payment, priced on the pricing page, and it sets the readings out by date next to title brands and accident records.

Checking one Maxima before you buy

  1. Read the VIN off the car itself and compare it with the seller's paperwork.
  2. Look the VIN up on NHTSA's recall tool and write down any open campaign.
  3. Pull the mileage history and look for a step backward or a long gap.
  4. Read the title records for salvage or flood brands, which the federal NMVTIS program exists to expose.
  5. Ask for service records covering the transmission, then book an independent inspection.

If a seller resists any step on that list, that tells you something the complaint table never could.

Mechanic inspecting a sedan beside four numbered Maxima checks

Where this information comes from

Sources and photos: Facts checked against the sources above in November 2026. Photos by Matthias Speicher, Mustafa Sheikhmouss and Dennis Eusebio on Unsplash; diagrams by UsedVehicleChecks.

Keep reading

Frequently asked questions

What are the worst years for the Nissan Maxima?

By NHTSA complaint volume, 2004 is worst with 1,426 filings, then 2005 with 948 and 2006 with 576. Most of the 2004 and 2005 complaints name the power train. Counts are owner reports, so use them to decide where to inspect hardest.

Is a 2004 Nissan Maxima a bad car?

It carries the most complaints of any year, 13.39 times the median, and 934 of them cite the power train. A well-documented example with service records may be fine, but price in a possible transmission repair and have it inspected.

Which Nissan Maxima years are the most reliable?

Complaint counts measure filings, not reliability. Years such as 2013 with 62 and 2008 with 79 run light, and recent years look clean partly because owners have had less time to file. Check recalls and mileage history for the exact VIN.

Does high mileage matter more than model year on a Maxima?

For a single car, usually yes. Model year tells you which batch it came from, while dated readings show how hard it was driven. Verify that readings rise in order and ask for transmission service records.

How do I check for open recalls on a used Maxima?

Use NHTSA's free recall lookup with the VIN. Recall repairs are free at a Nissan dealer. A VIN report can also list open recalls, though the federal lookup is the authoritative first stop.

Now check the car itself

The guide explains what to look for. The report shows what this VIN has on record.

Find the VIN on the driver's door jamb, at the base of the windshield, or on the registration and insurance card.